For anyone who hasn’t been following the news: on February 24th 2010, Dawn Brancheau, a whale trainer, died at SeaWorld Orlando, Florida, during an incident involving one of their ‘killer’ whales, Tillikum, lovingly called Tilly.
One witness, Victoria Biniak, told WKMG-TV that it was a violent scene. Tillikum took off really fast, grabbed Brancheau by her waist and “started thrashing around and one of her shoes flew off.”, while another said that the 40-year-old whale trainer was grabbed by her arm and pulled under and subsequently drowned.
Since her first visit to SeaWorld when she was a young girl, Brancheau knew she wanted to be a killer whale trainer and vocalized as such. Everyone knew about her dream to become a trainer and since 1994 she has been contracted by SeaWorld, the same place her dream of being a trainer was visualized.

Dawn Brancheau and friend during a performance on December 30, 2005 / Orlando Sentinel Files
Though this would be a very unfortunate mishap if it happened once, but this mishap wasn’t Tilly’s first; he was one of three Orca’s blamed for the 1991 death of trainer Keltie Byrene, who slipped and fell into the water and was dragged around and pulled under several times by Tillikum, Nootka 4 and Haida 2 at the now defunct Sealand of the Pacific in British Columbia before he was sold to Orlando and on another occasion in 1999, Tilly was found swimming around with a naked man on his back who, according to a report, died of hypothermia, but was bitten and disrobed by Tillikum.
While I can’t really comment on the naked guy and how much Tillikum is really to blame for that one, seeing as naked guy had snuck into his enclosure which, for me, is a clear sign he didn’t seem to be of sound mind, but the other occasions do raise a lot of questions. Not only questions for the safety of the humans, but the safety of the animals as well.
What makes an animal like that, one that has had to put his trust in his trainers hands for survival, snap like that? By all accounts he wasn’t mistreated by any of is trainers nor did it seem to be stress related. So what is it?
More importantly, what should happen to Tilly now? Most other animals, for instance dogs, would have been destroyed after just one kill, heck they most likely would have been destroyed after just 1 ’simple’ bite that would require stitches and some were not even their fault because they were either a) raised bad or b) were bullied and fought back. This animal was involved in three separate incidents involving human deaths (two of which were undoubtedly his, or partly his fault) and , as reported by staff, was considered an especially dangerous animal.
Dawn Brancheau was one of only less than half of the park’s 28 trainers who were allowed to work with Tillikum.
Though there were reports that Tillikum had been acting strangely, SeaWorld, Orlando’s curator for animal behaviour, Chuck Tompkins was quick to dismiss that notion and in fact, he said that just seconds before Tillikum dragged Brancheau into the water, the trainer was rewarding him for his good behaviour and how well he had performed that day.
So I ask again, if Tillikum was having a good day, what made him snap and kill his strainer, one of only a handful that was allowed to work with him and according to Jack Hanna, a personal friend and colleague, Dawn Brancheau was one of the, if not the best trainer in her field.
Was he just playing around? Did he panic for some unknown reason? Or did he just simply snap?
I can’t even begin to think on how I would deal with the question as to whether Tillikum should be destroyed or if he should be allowed to live out his life away from the public eye (heck, maybe even released back into the wild but that is a whole different ballgame which I won’t get into in this post).
All I know is that, from hearing and reading the reports, Dawn Brancheau was one of a kind. These animals were her passion, it was her life’s work. She knew the risks of working with these animals, these so-called ‘Killer Whales’ and I personally think that she wouldn’t want him destroyed.
What do you think happened?
What do you think should happen next?
Recent Comments